Comfortable and Furious

Christmas at Mistletoe Manor (2025)

Here at Ruthless Reviews, we love  to watch film, and to review the movies we watch, whether they be good, bad or ugly. We especially love Indie Film and Christmas movies. I am pleased to state that Christmas at Mistletoe Manor checks none of these boxes. In fact, good does not even begin to describe this gorgeous movie. It was magnificent. 

I am occasionally contacted by the creators of Indie film, offering to share screenings of their films. I try to review at least one Christmas movie per year from independent filmmakers. Shari at Happy Cheers was nice enough to send me a screening.  The network cut of this movie is available on the Great American Family Channel, so check it out for local showings. 

In this review, there will be a minimum of spoilers or plot details. We have Alice (Madeleine Coghlan) who is an incredibly cute and bubbly East Coast fledging YouTuber with a food channel. There is an early, but very appropriate reveal that sends her on a quest to a charming English castle, to put the remains of Hortense (her grandmother) to rest, and to try to unravel some of the mysteries of her ancestry. 

Mistletoe Manor is a stunning B&B, operated by a young and handsome Oliver Colby (Lior Selve) and his tight-lipped Alfred Pennyworth-like Valet Lorenzo (Federico Dordei). Alice has booked her stay for a week, and her ebullient quest at first annoyed Oliver and Lorenzo, but Oliver was quickly mesmerized by the focused and charming Alice. Oh boy, we knew or hoped we knew where this was headed. As layers of history are uncovered, will we be treated to the inevitability of a love story? Maybe I’ve written too much, you will just have to watch this one to find out.  


Christmas at Mistletoe Manor is a beautiful film directed by Shari Hamrick Grewal. From the opening scene, the cinematography is crisp and the sets and Christmas décor are simply gorgeous. The pacing was near perfect, and the film moved along smartly, and thankfully avoided any predictable Christmas movie tropes and religious or political baggage that so often torpedo holiday films. The acting skills of Alice, Oliver and Lorenzo were superior and the viewers of this film will be easily immersed with these genuine and believable performances.

As is typical of Indie films, this one was heavy on dialogue, but it did not fail to hold my attention for a single minute of the 1 hr. and 24 minute run-time. It was shot in San Bernardino Co., California, but I could have sworn that it was lensed in Jolly Ole England. Even with the chirpiness of Alice, Mistletoe Manor skillfully avoided the dreck and sappiness often seen in “Hallmark” type Christmas movies, and I greatly appreciated this.

I highly recommend this special treat of a movie for holiday viewing.

10.0/10.0 With the Goatesians Rating of must-see Indie Holiday Film



Posted

in

, , ,

by

Tags:

Comments

8 responses to “Christmas at Mistletoe Manor (2025)”

  1. Kelly Anthony Avatar
    Kelly Anthony

    Coghlin NEEDS allocution lessons and slow down! I have NEVER hear anyone’s speech so dam annoying as if she learned from a chipmunk ! Wt hell possesses her to speak in soundbites?? Also what ridiculous dragged on story about grandma typical Hallmark ! I immediately changed the channel.

    1. Goat Avatar
      Goat

      Did you ever consider that that was part of the very nature of her character?

  2. Shari Grewal Avatar

    I just heard that some of the playback was distorted. Not sure about the soundbites. But overall definitely was Character choice by Actor. That’s Alice! There are definitely rules of format in the storytelling in the holiday rom/com lane. You are so right, it’s a formula, and they all require these movies to try and stick as close to those rules as possible. If too different they do not get bought. These Christmas movies aren’t for everyone. For me I’m still all about Die Hard LOL. thanks for sharing your thoughts. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year 🙂

    1. Goat Avatar
      Goat

      There you go. I didn’t notice any type of distortion on my screener, and I watched it more than once. Again, I thought the presentation was spot-on.

    2. Carol Avatar
      Carol

      Why is this movie named christmas at Mistletoe Manor? There is no mention of mistletoe or it being a manor throughout the movie but rather takes place at a castle/B&B. Think the name is misleading.

      1. Goat Avatar
        Goat

        I’ll let Shari answer this one. Maybe because “Castle in the Sky” was taken? I’m more curious as to why something like this would be of concern to you.

      2. Shari Grewal Avatar

        Agree, but since you asked…. The original title was The Christmas Garden. But all titles are “working titles” subject to change at networks. Could be due to legal use clearances, sometimes just theme ideas. This movie also was called Winters’ Garden and even one was Mistletoe at the Manor. Lol!

  3. Layton Zhang Avatar
    Layton Zhang

    Good post! We will be linking to this particularly great post on our site. Keep up the great writing

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *